A few weeks ago the news hit the streets on LinkedIn discussions
that the 1st Microsoft 19770-2 compliant tag was
"seen in the
wild".
Here are the facts.
.
This asessment is based on Windows 8
Release Preview version 6.2.8400.0 (major = 6 minor = 2 build =
8400) which we believe is now, or will be soon, shipping to manufacturers.
The software 19770-2 tag detail provided by Microsoft in Windows
8 desktop shows only the mandatory data. There is no optional tag
elements and yet this is where the key data you will need is located
There are 7 Mandatory Elements–
Entitlement Required
– Product Title
– Product Version
– Software Creator
– Software Licensor
– Software Unique
ID
– Tag Creator
and 30 Optional Elements
– Product Category
– Components of a suite
–
Previous product or company names
– License Linkage Details
(activation status, channel, cust type)
– etc.
The full
19770-2 schema can be located directly at
http://standards.iso.org/iso/19770/-2/2009/schema.xsd
In
PCProfile's opinion, from a customer perspective, the information
provided by Microsoft supplying only the mandatory tags in
Windows 8 is no better than you can extract with existing Discovery
Tools.
In fact the data they provide with Windows 8 is less
than what is found under any Discovery audit with all tools on the
market.
Do not be fooled into thinking that tagging is going
to solve your problems, now or in the near future.
There is
a whole world of pain yet to be experienced with the 19770-2 tagging
approach as it does not come up to expectations.
An insight into the world of pain follows;
Why are there 2 different SWID tags located in 3 folders for
ONE installation of Windows 8? Example Tag 1 is located in 2 separate
folders on the PCFolder 1 C:\ProgramData\
Folder 2
C:\Windows\WinSxS\x86_microsoft.......................
19770-2 swid tag file for Windows 8<?xml
version="1.0" encoding="utf-8"?>
<software_identification_tag
xmlns="http://standards.iso.org/iso/19770/-2/2009/schema.xsd">
<entitlement_required_indicator>true</entitlement_required_indicator>
<product_title>Windows 8 Release Preview</product_title>
<product_version>
<name>6.2.8400.0</name>
<numeric>
<major>6</major>
<minor>2</minor>
<build>8400</build>
<review>0</review>
</numeric>
</product_version>
<software_creator>
<name>Microsoft Corporation</name>
<regid>regid.1991-06.com.microsoft</regid>
</software_creator>
<software_licensor>
<name>Microsoft Corporation</name>
<regid>regid.1991-06.com.microsoft</regid>
</software_licensor>
<software_id>
<unique_id>Windows-8-Release-Preview</unique_id>
<tag_creator_regid>regid.1991-06.com.microsoft</tag_creator_regid>
</software_id>
<tag_creator>
<name>Microsoft
Corporation</name>
<regid>regid.1991-06.com.microsoft</regid>
</tag_creator>
</software_identification_tag>
Example Tag 2 is located in separate folder to the above 2 tags
Folder 3 C:\Windows\WinSxS\x86_microsoft.......................
19770-2 swid tag file for Windows 8
<?xml version="1.0" encoding="utf-8"?>
<software_identification_tag
xmlns="http://standards.iso.org/iso/19770/-2/2009/schema.xsd">
<entitlement_required_indicator>true</entitlement_required_indicator>
<product_title>Windows 8 Release Preview with Media
Center</product_title>
<product_version>
<name>6.2.8400.0</name>
<numeric>
<major>6</major>
<minor>2</minor>
<build>8400</build>
<review>0</review>
</numeric>
</product_version>
<software_creator>
<name>Microsoft Corporation</name>
<regid>regid.1991-06.com.microsoft</regid>
</software_creator>
<software_licensor>
<name>Microsoft Corporation</name>
<regid>regid.1991-06.com.microsoft</regid>
</software_licensor>
<software_id>
<unique_id>Windows-8-Release-Preview-with-Media-Center</unique_id>
<tag_creator_regid>regid.1991-06.com.microsoft</tag_creator_regid>
</software_id>
<tag_creator>
<name>Microsoft
Corporation</name>
<regid>regid.1991-06.com.microsoft</regid>
</tag_creator>
</software_identification_tag>
Why are there 2 different
SWID tags located in 3 folders for ONE installation of Windows
8?
In order for
Discovery tools to provide you, the customer, accurate results,
they will need to be able to discern which specific tag they
should be analysing!
.................and now the fun
starts.
The Microsoft Windows 8 logo and references to Windows 8 and the
software tags are all recognised as Copyright to Microsoft. They
are listed here for informational purposes only.